Monday, June 23, 2008

Measure for Measure

No, not Shakespeare. Here's a blog that, at least at first glance, is a convergence of the many players in the arts blogging discussion. The blog in question is Measure for Measure. Let's count the levels of intrigue:

1. Overt subject matter: songwriting (hence the clever title)
2. Implied subject matter: Art. Or at least the creative process.
3. Written by: songwriters (famous ones, too. Andrew Bird, Roseanne Cash, Suzanne Vega, Darrell Brown
4. Blog host: New York Times. See, this is where it gets interesting. Andrew didn't call Roseanne one day and say, "Hey, let's start a blog and tell everyone what it's like to write a song. What's Suzanne up to--think she'd want to help out?" The Times is paying these contributors to write a "blog" (usually unnecessary quote marks quite necessary here), which will appear for a predetermined number of weeks, with scheduled entries, and the engine of one of the country's largest media outlets providing its power.

Is Measure for Measure a blog? NYTimes.com says so. But it's a very different creature than the umpteen million blogspot-powered one-man bands we might think of when we say blog. For that matter, it's a very different creature than the bigger bands, too (Alex Ross et al). And it's one being replicated by every newspaper and periodical of means in the country. Do these Big Blogs threaten the democratization of arts criticism that the blogosphere might be about? Do they stifle independent, small voices (and doesn't that sound familiar: maybe the questions never change, just the mediums do)? Or are they just part of the mix, adding to the unruly conversations virtually tripping over one another to get our attention?

The Closing

Can't well have a blog about the arts without mentioning the passing of a major theater from the Twin Cities landscape. Theatre de la Jeune Lune will cease operations in July, sell its building in the Warehouse District (it of the cool space and most uncomfortable seats in all of Theatredom), and after thirty years dissipate into the ether, leaving behind a 2005 Tony award, inventive interpretations of Mozart operas, and some maddeningly inscrutable Moliere. Love 'em or hate 'em (I've done both), the troupe's absence changes the region's (the nation's?) theater scene.

Friday, June 20, 2008

Thou sayest

My faculty collaborator has given me a couple questions to chew on this weekend, perhaps to decrease the time I spend thinking about font colors for the blog, but also to think more seriously about the critical underpinnings of this research. We meet weekly to discuss these and other issues, and writing weekly reflections on what I've been doing and thinking about is good practice for me, not simply from a writing perspective, but as a way of allowing myself to risk a path that might yield thorny, less-than-tidy answers—or more likely—thorny, less-than-tidy questions. I prefer being right.

I'd value your reflections on these questions as well (and I promise not to plagiarize from your comments). I'll add my own reflection here, too.

1. What do you think is the purpose of the art(s) critic in this cultural context?
2. What do you think should be the purpose of the art(s) critic in this cultural context?

If you infer from those questions a kind of good critic vs. bad critic dichotomy, feel free to explore that a bit. I'm all for judgment: as a kid, I would line up the 150+ nativity sets that my father collected, conducting an elaborate, points-based pageant to determine which Baby Jesus et familia had the most artistic integrity.

It's not easy being green

A couple of my esteemed colleagues at Hamline noted that the limey green I chose to use as an accent color here at Everyone's a Critic was, well, impossible to read (they were nicer about it than that). I chose that shade because its exuberance matched my own excitement for the project, but I have toned it down, bowing to pressures of readability. I hope the new, more somber green matches the Seriousness of Our Subject.

Tuesday, June 17, 2008

Everyone's a critic, indeed

Even the perfume critics (who knew?) are swelling the ranks of the blog world. It's a shame that the Times had to steal my title, though. Whatever happened to originality?

The plot thickens

In responding to my post about Michael Agger's article, Eric M draws parallels to the film industry's own version of writing for the page vs. Web: video vs. film. I commend his comments to you, but I want to highlight this statement of his:
We would be wise to accept that a blog critic can not (and should not) compete with a traditional critic using traditional methods, but instead should forge a new path using the strengths of the Internet to his/her advantage.
Agreed, but what happens as those traditional methods disappear? And they are disappearing. It would be terrific to be able to read meaty criticism in the local newspaper, then go online and find another take. But when the paper cuts the critic's position, should we be content with the bullet points of an online review? To be fair, blogging critics write long (and how), thoughtful reviews, but Agger notes that blogging is exempt from the rules of online writing. That is, we seek out blogs that match our interests, and are content to read patiently on blogs. But that means that the population reading the paper isn't going to see these reviews, or be aware they even exist. Do we care if the general populace has access to arts criticism, even if they don't give a whit about last week's concert of the Poughkeepsie Chamber Rock Music Festival?

Monday, June 16, 2008

Questions, questions, questions

In a thoughtful comment to my introductory post, jlderfner argues that the questions about music and work and class (and and and) may become more complicated as this project progresses. And he's right. One of the dangers of unrolling this project in blog form is exposing the incompleteness of the project's parameters, or the narrowness of my focus (I've only got ten weeks, at least for this funded part). I'm hoping, however, that if the smart people (meaning any of you who take the time to contribute to the conversation) keep jabbing me with comments, more questions will be exposed, and my research will be better.